Top 10 Ice Cream Shops in Brooklyn You Must Try in 2024

If you are looking for a good ice cream and you are in Brooklyn, then I must say you are in the place to be.

Brooklyn offers so many possibilities you will hardly have the time to try them all out in a short period.

To make it easier for you, I want to present you with my personal top 10.

I am certain you will find some of these to be to your liking.

10. Gelateria Gentile

Gelateria Gentile in Brooklyn

Gelateria Gentile is a slice of Italy right in Brooklyn.

Their authentic Italian gelato is made with rich, high-quality ingredients that transport you straight to the streets of Rome.

  • Address: 253 Wythe Ave, Williamsburg
  • Highlights: Authentic Italian gelato, rich flavors, fresh whipped cream topping
  • Working Hours: Monday to Sunday, 12 PM – 10 PM

The creamy texture and intense flavors of Gelateria Gentile’s offerings are unmatched.

My personal favorites include their classic pistachio and dark chocolate gelato, which are perfectly complemented by a generous dollop of fresh whipped cream.

The cozy ambiance and friendly service make it a must-visit spot for anyone craving a taste of Italy.

9. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream

Van Leeuwen Ice Cream is a staple in Brooklyn.

Known for its natural ice cream flavors and a variety of vegan options, this shop is perfect for both traditionalists and adventurous eaters.

  • Address: 204 Wythe Ave, Williamsburg & 81 Bergen St, Boerum Hill
  • Highlights: Natural ice cream flavors, vegan options, popular flavors like Earl Grey Tea and Salted Caramel
  • Working Hours: Monday to Sunday, 11 AM – 11 PM

Their Earl Grey Tea and Salted Caramel ice creams are some of the best I’ve ever tasted.

The use of high-quality, simple ingredients ensures that each scoop is bursting with flavor.

The vegan options are equally impressive, offering a creamy and satisfying alternative to dairy-based ice creams.

8. Lady Moo-Moo

Lady Moo-Moo in Brooklyn

Located at 365 Chauncey St in Bedford-Stuyvesant, Lady Moo-Moo is a hidden gem with excellent customer service and standout flavors that keep me coming back for more.

  • Address: 365 Chauncey St, Bedford-Stuyvesant
  • Highlights: Excellent customer service, standout flavors like Cookies and Cowfee, Chocolate Vanilla Pretzel
  • Working Hours: Friday to Sunday, 2 PM – 8 PM

The Cookies and Cowfee and Chocolate Vanilla Pretzel flavors are absolutely delicious, with each scoop offering a perfect balance of sweetness and texture.

The staff at Lady Moo-Moo are always friendly and ready to offer recommendations, making each visit a pleasant experience.

It’s a cozy spot that’s perfect for a relaxing ice cream treat.

7. Davey’s Ice Cream

Davey’s Ice Cream in Brooklyn

Davey’s Ice Cream prides itself on homemade ice cream made from natural ingredients.

The flavors here are both comforting and exciting, making it a favorite spot for many.

  • Address: 74 Meserole Ave, Greenpoint
  • Highlights: Homemade ice cream, natural ingredients, popular flavors like Strong Coffee, Speculoos Chocolate Chip
  • Working Hours: Monday to Sunday, 12 PM – 10 PM

I love the Strong Coffee and Speculoos Chocolate Chip flavors, which are incredibly rich and satisfying.

The commitment to using natural ingredients is evident in every bite, and the friendly atmosphere makes it a great place to unwind with a scoop (or two.)

Davey’s is a delightful spot that offers a perfect blend of classic and creative flavors.

6. Ample Hills Creamery

Ample Hills Creamery has multiple locations in Brooklyn, but the one I visit frequently is at 623 Vanderbilt Ave and 305 Nevins St.

It is known for its creative flavors and themed ice creams with mix-ins, this creamery is a playground for ice cream lovers.

  • Address: 623 Vanderbilt Ave, Prospect Heights & 305 Nevins St, Gowanus
  • Highlights: Creative flavors like Salted Crack Caramel and Ooey Gooey Butter Cake, themed ice creams with mix-ins
  • Working Hours: Monday to Sunday, 12 PM – 11 PM

The Salted Crack Caramel and Ooey Gooey Butter Cake flavors are my top picks, offering a perfect mix of sweet and salty with delightful textures.

The themed ice creams are always fun to try, and there’s always something new and exciting on the menu.

Ample Hills Creamery is a must-visit for anyone looking to indulge in some of the most inventive ice cream flavors in Brooklyn.

5. OddFellows Ice Cream Co

OddFellows Ice Cream Co in Brooklyn

OddFellows Ice Cream Co is famous for its unorthodox approach to flavors.

With over 500 different types of flavors created, there’s always something new to try.

  • Address: 44 Water St, Williamsburg
  • Highlights: Unique flavors like Peanut Butter S’Mores, Vegan Matcha Latte, more than 500 different types of flavors created
  • Working Hours: Monday to Sunday, 12 PM – 10 PM

The Peanut Butter S’Mores and Vegan Matcha Latte are just a few examples of their inventive offerings.

Each visit to OddFellows is a new adventure, with a rotating menu that keeps things fresh and exciting.

The quality and creativity of their ice cream make it a standout spot in Brooklyn’s ice cream scene.

4. Malai

Malai Ice Cream Shop in Brooklyn

Malai brings a unique twist to the ice cream scene with flavors inspired by South Asian ingredients.

Their offerings are both exotic and familiar, making for a delightful ice cream experience.

  • Address: 268 Smith St, Carroll Gardens
  • Highlights: Ice cream made with South Asian ingredients, flavors like Golden Turmeric, Red Chili Chocolate, and vegan options
  • Working Hours: Monday to Sunday, 12 PM – 10 PM

I particularly enjoy the Golden Turmeric and Red Chili Chocolate flavors, which offer a perfect blend of spice and sweetness.

Malai’s innovative use of South Asian spices and ingredients makes their ice cream truly unique.

The cozy shop and friendly staff add to the charm, making it a great place to explore new flavors.

3. Island Pops

Island Pops in Brooklyn

Island Pops offers a taste of the Caribbean with their tropical flavors and refreshing popsicles.

It’s a perfect spot to cool down on a hot day.

  • Address: 680 Nostrand Ave, Crown Heights
  • Highlights: Tropical Caribbean flavors, popsicles, sorbet, seasonal flavors like Pumpkin Coconut
  • Working Hours: Tuesday to Sunday, 1 PM – 9 PM

The Pumpkin Coconut and other tropical flavors are refreshing and delicious.

The popsicles and sorbets are made with fresh, high-quality ingredients, bringing a burst of flavor in every bite.

Island Pops is a fantastic place to enjoy some refreshing ice cream treats.

2. Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory

Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory is known for its classic flavors and historical ambiance near the Brooklyn Bridge.

  • Address: 14 Old Fulton St, Brooklyn Heights
  • Highlights: Classic flavors like Chocolate, Coffee, Butter Pecan, near Brooklyn Bridge with a historical ambiance
  • Working Hours: Open daily from 12 PM to 10 PM

Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory offers a nostalgic ice cream experience with its classic flavors and charming location.

Enjoying a scoop of their Coffee or Butter Pecan ice cream while taking in the views of the Brooklyn Bridge is a must-do for both locals and visitors.

1. Taiyaki NYC

Taiyaki NYC in Brooklyn

Taiyaki NYC offers a twist on ice cream with its fish-shaped cones. But its not just that, the flavors themselves are nothing short of exceptional. That is why I adore it so much.

  • Address: 294 Bedford Ave, Williamsburg
  • Highlights: Unique fish-shaped cones, flavors like matcha and hojicha, build-your-own options
  • Working Hours: Open daily from 12 PM to 10 PM

Taiyaki NYC’s fish-shaped cones are as delightful to look at as they are to eat.

The matcha and hojicha flavors are both delicious and pair perfectly with the whimsical cones.

The option to build your own cone adds more fun to the experience.


Brooklyn’s ice cream shops are more than just places to get a sweet treat—they’re destinations that encapsulate the borough’s eclectic and innovative spirit.

So, take a delightful experience through these ice cream havens, savor the unique offerings, and find your slice of ice cream paradise.

Whether you’re exploring Williamsburg in the summer or another vibrant neighborhood, there’s always a new flavor to discover.

In Brooklyn, every scoop celebrates flavor, creativity, and community.